TL;DR
Compliance carbon markets are legally required systems for trading emissions allowances, while voluntary markets let companies and individuals offset unavoidable emissions through certified projects. Both play a role, but reducing emissions should always come first.
Introduction
Carbon markets are one of the most practical tools we have in the fight against climate change, and they’re not just for big corporations. They create a way to turn climate action into measurable, trackable results by trading carbon credits, each one representing one tonne of CO2 (or equivalent greenhouse gas) reduced or removed from the atmosphere.
Two distinct types of carbon markets shape our climate action landscape:
Compliance Carbon Markets (such as EU ETS): Regulated systems where high-emission industries must meet specific emission reduction targets
Voluntary Carbon Markets: Platforms where organizations and individuals choose to offset their emissions through certified projects
Understanding these markets is crucial for businesses developing their sustainability strategies. The differences between compliance and voluntary markets affect how you can participate, what standards apply (such as Gold Standard, VCS, or Plan Vivo), and the costs involved.
This article explores:
Key characteristics of each market type
Cost implications and environmental impact
Future market trends
How to integrate carbon credits into your sustainability strategy
The role of expert intermediaries in accessing these markets
Understanding Carbon Markets
Carbon markets are economic tools created to fight climate change by allowing the buying and selling of carbon credits. A carbon credit represents the reduction or removal of one metric ton of carbon dioxide (CO₂) or its equivalent from the atmosphere.
How Carbon Markets Work
The basic idea behind carbon markets is simple: organizations can buy and sell carbon credits to help meet their emission reduction goals. This creates a financial incentive to cut greenhouse gas emissions while allowing flexibility in how those reductions are achieved. For example, a logistics company might purchase credits from a certified wind farm project to balance out emissions from its delivery fleet while it transitions to electric vehicles.
Key Mechanisms for Emission Reduction
In carbon markets, there are several main ways to reduce greenhouse gas emissions:
Cap and Trade Systems: Governments establish emission limits for specific industries.
Carbon Offsetting: Investments are made in projects that either reduce or eliminate emissions.
Direct Trading: Carbon credits are bought and sold directly between organizations.
Types of Projects Supported by Carbon Markets
Carbon markets support various types of projects that contribute to emission reductions, including:
Renewable energy installations
Forest conservation and reforestation efforts
Improvements in energy efficiency
Methane capture initiatives at landfills
Adoption of sustainable agriculture practices
Factors Influencing Carbon Credit Prices
The prices of carbon credits are determined by supply and demand factors and can vary based on:
The quality of the project and its verification standards
The geographical location where the project is implemented
The specific type of emission reduction activity being undertaken
The overall market conditions and any regulatory requirements in place
These market mechanisms create a financial framework that encourages businesses to invest in sustainable practices while supporting global climate action goals.
Types of Carbon Markets
Carbon markets operate through two distinct systems: compliance markets and voluntary markets. Each serves specific purposes and operates under different frameworks.
1. Compliance Carbon Markets (such as EU ETS)
Compliance markets function through mandatory cap-and-trade systems. The European Union Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) stands as the world's largest carbon market, covering approximately 40% of EU greenhouse gas emissions. For example, under the EU ETS, an airline might need to buy extra allowances if its flights produce more CO2 than its cap allows.
Under this system:
Industries receive or buy emission allowances
Companies trade these allowances based on their needs
A decreasing emissions cap ensures steady reduction
Non-compliance results in heavy penalties
2. Voluntary Carbon Markets
The voluntary carbon market enables businesses and individuals to offset emissions through their own initiative. This market operates through various standards such as:
Verified Carbon Standard (VCS): The most widely used standard, ensuring project quality
Gold Standard: Focus on sustainable development alongside emissions reduction
Plan Vivo: Specializes in community-based land use projects
Climate Action Reserve (CAR): Emphasizes North American offset projects
These markets support diverse project types like:
Renewable energy installations
Forest conservation
Methane capture
Energy efficiency improvements
The voluntary market's flexibility allows for project development and implementation innovation, while compliance markets drive systematic emissions reductions across major industries.
Key Differences Between Compliance and Voluntary Carbon Markets
Regulation vs. Flexibility
Compliance carbon markets operate under strict regulatory frameworks with mandatory participation requirements. These markets enforce specific emission reduction targets through legally binding mechanisms. Companies in regulated sectors must:
Meet predetermined emission caps
Report emissions regularly to authorities
Face penalties for non-compliance
Follow standardized trading procedures
Voluntary carbon markets offer a more flexible approach, allowing organizations to:
Choose their emission reduction targets
Select preferred carbon offset projects
Determine their investment timeline
Adapt strategies based on organizational goals
Cost Implications and Environmental Impact
Cost Structures
The cost of carbon credits can vary widely, and understanding why helps you make smarter choices.
In compliance markets (like the EU ETS), prices are generally higher because supply is limited by regulation and demand is mandatory. In 2024, EU ETS prices often sat between €80–€90 per tonne. In voluntary markets, prices range from around $5 to $15 per tonne, depending on the project’s type, quality, and location. For instance, a small design agency in Amsterdam might choose to support a Gold Standard wind project in India at $12 per tonne, knowing it directly displaces coal‑fired electricity.
Environmental Effectiveness
Compliance markets drive systematic emission reductions through:
Mandatory participation of high-emission industries
Stringent verification processes
Clear enforcement mechanisms
Regular monitoring and reporting requirements
Voluntary markets contribute to environmental goals through:
Innovation in carbon reduction technologies
Support for diverse environmental projects
Engagement of smaller organizations
Funding for community-based initiatives
The distinct characteristics of each market create complementary approaches to emission reduction. Compliance markets ensure large-scale industrial changes, while voluntary markets enable broader participation and creative solutions. Both markets play crucial roles in achieving global climate targets, with compliance markets driving systematic change and voluntary markets fostering innovation and accessibility.
Future Trends in Carbon Markets
The carbon market is changing quickly because of ambitious climate goals and new technologies. Experts predict significant growth in both mandatory and voluntary carbon markets, with the voluntary market expected to reach $10-25 billion by 2030.
Shifts in Market Dynamics
Corporations and governments committing to net-zero emissions are reshaping how the carbon market operates. These commitments lead to a higher demand for top-quality carbon offsets, resulting in:
Stricter verification standards
Enhanced project transparency
Higher prices for premium carbon credits
Innovative carbon removal technologies
The role of carbon credits in your sustainability strategy
Carbon credits play a vital role in your sustainability journey, but they're not the first step. A robust sustainability strategy follows a clear hierarchy:
1. Measure your emissions
Use a reliable footprint calculator or work with an expert to map your emissions. This shows you where your biggest impacts are and sets a baseline for action.
2. Reduce emissions at source
Tackle the easy wins first: switch to renewable energy, improve efficiency, optimize transport, and rethink supply chain choices. For example, a catering business can cut emissions by moving to a hybrid delivery fleet and sourcing seasonal produce locally.
3. Offset remaining emissions
Once you’ve reduced what you can, offset the rest by purchasing high‑quality carbon credits from verified environmental projects. Choose initiatives that deliver real, measurable benefits (from protecting forests to expanding renewable energy) and track your impact so you can report it with confidence.
Carbon credits serve as a powerful tool to address unavoidable emissions while contributing to global climate action. When you invest in carbon credits, you support innovative environmental projects, help develop sustainable technologies, and create positive social impact in project communities. This demonstrates environmental leadership and commitment to sustainability, showcasing your organization's dedication to making a meaningful difference in the fight against climate change.
Regreener as your Expert in the Voluntary Carbon Market
At Regreener, we make it simple for you to take credible climate action through the voluntary carbon market. Whether you’re a small team just starting your sustainability journey or an established business looking to deepen your impact, we help you navigate the world of carbon credits with confidence.
Project criteria ensuring quality
Each project in Regreener’s portfolio undergoes rigorous verification to ensure genuine environmental impact. We apply the following criteria to select the most impactful climate project partnerships:
CO₂ Additionality: Does the project truly result in emission reductions or other environmental benefits beyond what would have happened in a baseline scenario without the project?
Data Transparency: Is there sufficient and reliable data available to verify the project’s impact?
Permanence: Is the project's positive impact on the climate secured in the long term?
Social Value: To what extent does the project contribute to the economic and social well-being of local communities?
Tracking the Impact of Your Climate Project Investments
Our platform offers transparent tracking tools that allow you to monitor the direct impact of your contributions through clear, measurable metrics, such as:
Tonnes of CO2 compensated
Trees planted
Hectares of rainforest protected
Square meters of coral restored
Regreener’s comprehensive approach makes us your one-stop shop for all climate strategy needs, from carbon footprint calculation and impact reporting to ongoing support. We help businesses maximize their sustainability efforts through effective emission reductions and high-impact climate projects.
On our Climate Projects page, you’ll find an overview of the impactful projects we’ve partnered with.
Feel free to reach out to one of our experts to learn more about how your business can make a difference.
Conclusion
The path to a sustainable future requires active participation from businesses in both compliance and voluntary carbon markets. These markets are powerful tools in the global fight against climate change, each playing a distinct yet complementary role. However, carbon credits complement - not replace - direct emission reduction efforts. A balanced approach combining internal reductions with strategic offsetting creates the most effective path to sustainability.
Your business can make a meaningful impact by:
Measuring your current carbon footprint to gain insight into your emissions
Reducing the emissions you can eliminate in a cost-effective way
Offsetting unavoidable emissions by supporting innovative, verified climate projects
By taking these steps, your business not only contributes to global emission reduction targets, but also strengthens its brand reputation and long-term value.
Looking for extra info?
Explore our FAQ guide.
